Site amalgamation means joining two or more neighbouring lots into one development site. Owners in the Sutherland Shire do it when a single block is too small or too narrow for the housing the planning rules allow, and the combined site is not.
Why lot size matters
Many planning standards set a minimum lot size and width. The Local Environmental Plan sets minimum lot sizes, and State policies set their own as well. Under the NSW Low and Mid-Rise Housing Policy, townhouses in the areas it covers need a lot of at least 600 square metres and 12 metres wide, and terraces need at least 500 square metres and 18 metres wide.
A typical suburban block can fall short of one of those numbers on its own. Two blocks side by side often clear it with room to spare, and a wider frontage gives the architect more to work with. In the Shire, the policy applies around centres such as Miranda, Sutherland and Engadine, and our note on low and mid-rise housing in the Sutherland Shire lists them all.
The lot that gets left behind
Amalgamation has a second side. If a project joins several lots and leaves one out, that lot can end up isolated: too small to develop by itself, and sitting beside a much larger building.
The Land and Environment Court has a planning principle on this situation, and it came from a case in this council area: Karavellas v Sutherland Shire Council [2004] NSWLEC 251. The principle deals with the isolation of a site by the redevelopment of the sites next to it, and with how the Court looks at the negotiations between the owners. The Court describes a planning principle as a statement of a desirable outcome, or a list of matters to consider, in making a planning decision.
The lesson for owners is simple. If your lot would be left out of a neighbour’s project, or your project would leave a neighbour out, raise it early and get planning and legal advice, because the Court looks at those negotiations.
How neighbours work together
A group sale or a group development goes better when the owners settle the big questions in order:
- Talk early. Find out which neighbours are interested, and listen to what each one wants from the outcome. One owner wants a quick sale and another wants to stay in the street, and both answers are fair.
- Test the combined site. A feasibility study on the joined lots shows what they can hold together and what each lot adds to the whole.
- Agree how the value is shared. Each owner needs their own solicitor and their own advice on value. A deal that feels fair to every owner on the day it is signed is far more likely to hold.
- Choose the path. The owners can sell together to one buyer, or keep a stake in what gets built.
What makes a combined site work
A combined site is judged on more than its total area. Frontage to the street decides how wide the building can be and where cars get in and out. The slope of the land changes the cost of a basement, and a corner position can give a second street to build to. One lot in the group with a constraint such as flooding or a heritage item can change what the whole site holds, so each lot is checked on its own before the group commits.
Selling together or staying in
A joint sale gives each owner a price and a clean exit. Some owners would rather stay involved and share in what the site becomes. In a development joint venture, the landowner brings the land and we bring the finance and delivery solution. With several owners, each one has to be comfortable with the terms, so expect that conversation to take time.
Whichever path you choose, order a planning certificate for each lot first, so every owner is working from the same facts about zoning, controls and constraints.
Our place in the Shire
We are based in the Shire, with our office in Caringbah, and our planning work covers feasibility studies, planning proposals, development applications, and HDA and SSDA proposals. We procure, plan, develop and deliver our own projects, and we partner with landowners who want to realise the most out of their properties.
This is general information, not legal or financial advice. If you and your neighbours are weighing up what your lots could hold together, talk to us.
